AVSN: Does the AVSN Profit Meryl Dorey?
AVSN Pays Meryl DoreyIn early 2005 Meryl Dorey wrote a long letter to AVSN subscribers about AVSN finances, what the organisation needed to continue and pleading for more donations, saying she couldn't even buy her kids any veggies one day because she used the last of her money to pay an AVN bill. This letter was published in AVSN's magazine supplement The Inside Edition (Vol 3.1, 2005) and was posted by Meryl Dorey to the AVSN Yahoo! group on 19 March 2005.
Further along in the letter in section "My personal wish list" we see one of her wishes is to get paid (excerpt):
"I would like to get paid for my work. Yes, we are a charity and yes, I am a volunteer. But for my work for the magazine at least, it would be nice to finally get some payment. I know my husband would be happy. We have done without for a lot of years to help the AVN, it would be nice if we were in a position where they [sic] AVN could help us out a bit. I was thinking of a payment of $300 a week if we have the funds. I would like to know what the rest of our members think about that."
I can't find any mentions by Dorey whether or not this payment went ahead. What we can see in the AVSN financial statements for 2007 & 2008 are the following expense items:
- 2007: Editing Fees $15,840.00
- 2008: Editors Charges $17,490
We don't know when these payments to Meryl Dorey commenced because 1) she won't tell anyone, and 2) no other financial statements itemised this entry. We do know payments to Dorey continued until January 2013 when the AVSN announced in a Jan 2013 e-newsletter that Living Wisdom magazine was ceasing production and "Meryl Dorey is no longer drawing a payment as Editor of Living Wisdom magazine".
We also don't know how much Meryl Dorey was paying herself after 2008 but bear in mind the AVSN failed to publish 13 magazines subscribers had paid for between January 2010 and December 2012. Based on previous experience I suspect she gave herself more payrises. And be aware that the AVSN posted a $32,925 total LOSS for the years 2011 and 2012 (incidently, that loss amounts to $316.58 per week). I doubt Dorey will ever divulge what she got paid by this supposedly volunteer-run, charitable organisation.
NOTE: As far as I'm aware, Dorey has never received a wage from the AVSN. These payments might be considered compensation for services rendered and therefore not necessarily outside the rules and regulations for associations and charities. What smells off about these payments is Dorey refusing to divulge to her members how much money she's been paid. As a charitable organisation (at the time) these sort of payments should not be hidden. The payments Dorey received for 2010, 2011 and 2012 are the most important. That three year period saw only 5 magazines published, so one would expect a corresponding decrease in payments to the magazine editor. If there was no decrease, then the pretence of Dorey being compensated as editor is over and opens a big can of worms for the AVSN.
Dorey House ExtensionMarch 2005. Meryl Dorey and the AVSN launch a Bankruptcy Appeal, advising members and supporters that if the organisation doesn't urgently receive $20,000 in donations to allow the AVN to continue (and $50,000 to be stable) she'll be contacting the necessary authorities on Monday to discuss putting the AVN into bankruptcy and folding the organisation. She goes on to say that if no one gives money then next week she'll be closing the email list down, disconnecting the phones and stopping production of the next issue of Informed Choice magazine (which was already at the printers, she adds).
Please note: this appeared in the same edition of The Inside Edition where she asked to be paid. Yes, really.
July 2005. The Inside Edition (Vol 3.2) section "The AVN wish list", Dorey writes (excerpt):
"Perhaps the amazing response to our bankruptcy appeal has made us bold? Perhaps it's just time to let you all know about a few things that are needed to help this organisation run better and more smoothly."
"1. We are squished! The AVN runs out of Meryl Dorey's home and, whilst the basement is a good size, it is now completely jam-packed. There are 4 people who work there on a regular bases (Meryl, Greta, Judy and Sarita) and one person who comes in every 2 to 3 weeks (Mina who usually works from her home on the Gold Coast). We have been renting a shipping container for the last couple of years to handle the overlfow of paperwork and books, but even with that extra space, we barely have room to breathe. If you are a draftsman or architect and would be willing to help us out with drawing up plans for a bargain basement price, please let us know. If you are a builder in the North Coast of NSW or Southern QLD who would also like to put in a bid on this project, we would love to hear from you."
That must have been one hell of a fundraising drive. Dorey explained back in February that the AVSN required $50,000 just "to get to the point where we are not always borrowing from Peter to pay Paul." And now the AVSN can afford to go ahead with a house extension. Or maybe Dorey is simply confident (bold!) she'll be able to raise the funds from AVSN members and supporters for anything she wants from now on.
October 2005. The Inside Edition (Vol 3.3) Dorey writes:
Back in March 2005, we were within 24 hours of declaring bankruptcy and closing our doors for good.And in the section entitled "The AVN wish list" we get an update on the house extension:
All of you, our wonderful members, came through and saved our organisation so we could continue our vital work.
Plans are now being drawn up for an extension to Meryl's home which houses the head office of the AVN.
Thanks to some volunteer drafting/architect work, ground should be broken early in 2006. This will give us more room to operate and hopefully allow us all to breathe and move without falling over each other!
We are still looking for a builder who would like to do some lower-cost work for this project. In addition, we will need a items such as a sink, toilet, kitchen cupboards, a bar fridge/small fridge and perhaps some second-hand windows/timber as wel. A small kitchen table and some chairs, perhaps a couple of easy chairs too would be great if you have any in decent condition that are not being used/needed?"
January 2006. Surprise! After Dorey telling us in October she expects the house extension to commence early 2006, the AVSN began promoting FOUR fundraising appeals:
- target $20,000 - for lobbying
- target $17,000 - for advertising AVN in Bounty Bag
- target $10,000 - to test vaccines for heavy metals
- target $5,000 - to pay for AVN 1-800 number
After October 2005 I can't find any further mention of the house extension but I also don't see Dorey complaining about the cramped quarters. Assuming this house extension did go ahead, I pose the following questions to Meryl Dorey:
- what was the total cost of the house extension?
- what percentage of this cost did the AVSN pay?
- if AVSN did pay for all or part of it, did any of the funds come from fundraising appeals for other purposes?
- by what amount has this extension increased the value of your house?
- have you ever charged the AVSN rent for use of this space? If so, how much?
- is there a formal agreement in place between yourself and the AVSN in regard to the extension in the event of the AVSN closing or you leaving the organisation? If so, what was agreed?
And while we're here, let's take a quick look at AVSN expenses (not including cost of goods sold).
* 2007 and 2008 statements were fully itemised; I have totalled these items in "Other" expenses.
What stands out to me is the increase in consultants fees in 2005 and increase in expenses in 2005 and 2006, with all these falling again from 2007.
So, did the house extension go ahead or not? Over to you, Meryl.
Posted: 29 Mar 2014